VINEGAR REMEDIES
(Investigator 200, 2021 September)
Like garlic to ward off vampires, vinegar remedies are based on
traditional and historical practices. Some of which however, do have a
practical application.
Believed to have been discovered accidently — a jar of wine left
uncovered and transformed into vinegar, it was a popular drink in the
days of the Roman Empire. Prior to that, in Assyria, vinegar was used
to treat ear-ache, and the Bible mentions its use for treating wounds
and sores. Hippocrates treated respiratory diseases with vinegar and
pepper around 400 B.C.
In the 1860s, Louis Pasteur discovered that the action of bacteria
caused wine to be converted to acid and water, and twenty years later,
a microbiologist by the name of Hansen identified three kinds of
vinegar bacilli.
According to proponents, apple cider vinegar contains a whole host of
vitamins, minerals and other nutrients, and it is recommended as a
daily tonic. Therapeutically, vinegar has been recommended by
proponents for just about everything, including sore throats, ear
infections, nose bleed, stings, headaches, hiccoughs, nausea, urinary
tract infections, asthma and even to help prevent cancer. The latter it
is claimed, due to beta-carotene in apple cider vinegar that
strengthens the immune system.
Other than the well established antidote for stings, how do the claims
for this wonder liquid hold up under scientific scrutiny? Not very well
I’m afraid. Vinegar is a poor source of essential nutrients. It
contains no pectin or beta-carotene, only a trace of calcium, iron or
protein, and miniscule amounts of amino acids.
In America recently, Jack McWilliams, the owner of Third Option
Laboratories, Muscle Shoals, Alabama, was served a court order to
destroy 13,320 half-gallon bottles of Jogging in a Jug — a mixture of
grape juice, apple juice and vinegar — because the product became an
unapproved new drug due to health claims made by promoters. Jack
McWilliams claimed that his vinegar product had helped him conquer his
own arthritis and heart disease, and could reduce the risk of cancer in
the internal organs. McWilliams claimed that the reason women craved
pickles during pregnancy was because they wanted acetic acid (vinegar).
Despite the court-ordered destruction of these jugs, Third Option
Laboratories is still in business and is working with the FDA on ways
to market the product legally. Company officials met with FDA in 1992
and agreed to stop making health claims but complaints continued,
resulting in action on May 19, 1994 that led to the court-ordered
destruction.
Even the authors of books extolling the virtues of vinegar add
disclaimers such as, "The publisher is not in any way rendering medical
advice and does not intend to replace the advice and care of those in
the medical profession". "The publisher makes no claims as to the
safety, effectiveness, or precision of any of the remedies or
suggestions in this book." Another cautions, "...these are only folk
remedies, not scientifically proven cures, no claims are intended as to
the safety, or endorsing the effectiveness, of any of the remedies."
Caveat emptor!
References:
Cardwell, Glenn. 1996. Vinegar can be used for What? the Skeptic, 16(1):32-33. Australian Skeptics Inc.
Food and Drug Administration, Consumer, Jan-Feb, 1996, p.35-6
Jarvis, D. C. 1958, Folk Medicine, Pan Books, London.
Tayler, Joanna. The Wonders of Vinegar, Pan Macmillan, Australia Pty. Ltd.
Thacker, Emily. 1994. The Vinegar Book, Tresco Publishers.
H.
Edwards, H. 1999 Alternative, Complementary, Holistic & Spiritual Healing, Australian Skeptics Inc.