|
SPACEWATCH, SPACEGUARD and the BIBLE Part 3
The Sodom and Gomorrah Connection Anonymous
(Investigator Magazine 185, 2019, March) HEADLINES
Sodom and Gomorrah and their destruction by "fire and brimstone", long criticized as myth by skeptics and atheists, look close to being confirmed. Attention-grabbing headlines in 2018 included: (K. Hignett, Newsweek 11/22/18) • An exploding meteor may have wiped out ancient Dead Sea Communities (The Spaceguard Centre, 22 November 2018) • Biblical cities were destroyed by mid-air asteroid explosion 500 times bigger than Hiroshima 3,700 years ago, archaeologists claim (J. Brophy, The Sun 23 November, 2018) • Evidence suggests enormous blast of heat wiped out Sodom and Gomorrah (P. Farquhar, Business Insider) Part I of "Spacewatch, Spaceguard and the Bible" in Investigator #171: b. Pointed out that 1700 "potentially hazardous Near Earth Objects" were known by 2016; c. Described the worldwide reaction if an unstoppable, large asteroid on a collision course with Earth is discovered. Part 2 (Investigator #176) examined biblical passages that apparently predict the "the end of the world" by an impact from Space. Now in Part 3 we investigate the historicity of Sodom and Gomorrah. The New Testament says their destruction foreshadowed what will happen wordwide, but this prediction is undermined by critics claiming that the cities and their destruction are myth. If all the critics are wrong, however, then the prediction is backed up not only by modern discoveries about asteroids but also by the historicity of the cities, and therefore deserves everyone's full attention and appropriate action. EXCAVATION PROJECT
The Tall El-Hammam Excavation Project at the northern tip of the Dead Sea has proceeded for thirteen seasons. It is the joint project of the archaeology departments of two American universities and the Department of Antiquities of the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan. A Conference Paper titled "The 3.7kaBP Middle Ghor Event: Catastrophic Termination of a Bronze Age Civilization" presented the Project's preliminary findings and says:
COMPARISONS
Civilization in the region now known as the Middle Ghor started before 4000 BCE and consisted of agricultural communities with mud-brick buildings. If the Bronze Age town of Tall el-Hammam is the Sodom of the Bible as its archaeologists suggest, then the region around it was unusually prosperous: Lot looked about him,
and saw that the plain of the Jordan was well-watered everywhere like
the
garden of the LORD … before the LORD had destroyed Sodom and Gomorrah. (Genesis 13:10) The prosperity lasted about 2500 years followed by sudden destruction, dated by carbon-dating to around 1700 BCE. The fiery explosion in the sky was almost as hot as the surface of the Sun, and blasted a circle of devastation 25 km across, flattened the mud-brick walls of over 100 small settlements leaving only stone foundations, melted the surface of pottery turning it to glass, stripped away the once fertile soil, instantly killed an estimated 50,000 people, sent a tsunami of super-heated Dead Sea brine over the region, and ended civilization in the area for over 600 years. Communities to the west in what later became known as Judah and Israel apparently continued without interruption. The Middle Ghor explosion is estimated at 10 megatons. This makes it 500 times bigger than the atomic bomb blasts that destroyed Hiroshima and Nagasaki in 1945, and 20 times bigger than the airburst above Chelyabinsk, Russia, in 2013 which damaged 6000 buildings in six cities and injured 1500 people. The Middle Ghor explosion was, however, smaller than the explosion over the Tunguska River region of Siberia in 1908 when a 50-100 meter asteroid disintegrated in the sky with a 15-megaton blast that devastated 2000 square kilometres and pushed over 80 million trees. LOCATION
Convention has long situated Sodom and Gomorrah east or south of the Dead Sea. The Tall El-Hammam Excavation Project in contrast situates the cities north of the Dead Sea. Bible dictionaries and atlases have generally been non-specific on their location and often added question marks when showing them on maps. Cases in point are Atlas of the Bible Lands (1984) and Bible Atlas (2008). The Bible locates Sodom and Gomorrah on a large plain and says that everything on the Plain would be "consumed" — safety lay beyond the Plain in the hills. (Genesis 13:10; 19:17) After the destruction: Abraham … looked down
toward Sodom and Gomorrah and toward all the land of the Plain and saw
the smoke of the land going up like the smoke of a furnace. (19:27-28) CRITICISM
Sodom's and Gomorrah's unknown location and the seeming absurdity of fire and rocks falling from the sky are why skeptics and critics long regarded the Bible's report as myth. Today's worldwide consciousness of asteroids started only recently, in 1980, with the discovery that a 10-km-wide asteroid impacted and caused mega-tsunamis, set sky and continents on fire, and wiped out the dinosaurs 66 million years ago. Occasional reports of stones falling from the sky in the 19th century were considered nonsense by scientists. Walter Rast (1930- ) was an archaeologist, a university professor of Theology, and author of Tradition, History and the Old Testament (1972) and Through The Ages In Palestinian Archaeology (1992). Collins (2007) presents Rast's view as follows: Rast did not believe in
the historicity of Abraham and Lot, nor in the literal story of the
divine destruction
of Sodom and Gomorrah... Rast believed that the biblical story of Sodom was an etiological legend that the Israelites likely picked up from local Canaanite lore, later spliced into the patriarchal narratives of Genesis by a Judahite priest during the late Iron Age. Australian atheist Brian de Kretser, writing on "The Bible A Fairy Storybook", claimed: But historians and
scientific research show that it's nothing but myths, fairy tales and
outright lies
<>
written by ignorant men… The Sodom and Gomorrah myth recycled from the Epic of Gilgamesh… (Investigator #123) Google's search results for Sodom and Gomorrah bring up many pages where the cities and their destruction are called "myth". MISTAKEN IDEAS
The evidence for Tall El-Hammam and Middle Ghor looks convincing, stronger than other interpretations that also seemed convincing to some people but were wrong. Bab edh-Dhra on the east side of the Dead Sea has often been suggested as the site of Sodom, and Numeira 16km south as Gomorrah:
<>
Archaeologist P.W. Lapp (1930-1970) excavated at Bab
edh-Dhra in 1965-1967 and estimated that the cemetery there had the
remains of 500,000 people. However, Bab edh-Dhra and Numeira cannot be
Sodom and Gomorrah because both were abandoned centuries before Abraham
and Lot lived!
<>
<> <>
The traditional view of Sodom and Gomorrah situated south of the Dead
Sea was defended in 2007 by biblical archaeologist Bryant G. Wood.
Steven Collins (2007), Director of the Tall El-Hammam Excavation
Project, responded advocating the northern location.
<>
<> <>
In 1989 Y.K. Bentor argued an earthquake destroyed Sodom and Gomorrah
but he could not explain the fire from heaven, therefore suggested it
was a flood which the Bible writer changed to fire for greater dramatic
effect.
<>
<> <>
Others noted the presence of "bitumen pits" (Genesis 14:10) and
suggested destruction of the cities by the explosion of underground
petroleum or gases. Another group believed an earthquake and/or
landslide slid the cities into the Dead Sea and left their remains
submerged.
<>
<> A scientifically argued explanation is by Gilat and Vol (2015). Their Abstract says in part: <>
In 2008 two British aerospace engineers, Alan Bond and Mark Hempsell suggested in a self-published book that an asteroid destroyed Sodom and Gomorrah in 3123 BCE besides causing a giant landslide in the Austrian Alps. The Australian reported in 2008: "Mark Hempsell, one of the researchers … said the size and route of the asteroid meant it was likely to have crashed into the Austrian Alps at Kofels [where] there is evidence of an ancient landslide 5km wide and 500m thick." Of course 3123 BCE is way off the usual biblical calculations for Sodom and Gomorrah of about 1900 BCE. Furthermore, RationalWiki points out that the Köfels landslide in the Austrian Alps was not caused by an asteroid, and did not occur in 3123 BCE but over 4500 years earlier: "The Köfels site has been dated with radiocarbon dating of wood buried by the landslide to about 9800±100 BP (Before Present)..." The date of 1700 BCE by the Tall El-Hammam archaeologists differs too from biblical chronology. But here the difference is only 200 years — therefore perhaps reconcilable. II PETER 2 & 3
As a Bible-investigating young person in 1970 I noted in II Peter 3 the description of the end of the world by fire which is preceded by a "loud noise". The previous chapter (II Peter 2) says Sodom and Gomorrah were "turned to ashes" and calls this "an example of what is coming to the ungodly". I concluded that the Bible's description agrees with what the impacts of asteroids or comets would do. I argued this in Investigator Magazine in the article "Earth And Sky On Fire At Christ's Return — How?" (#43, July 1995) Then again in #62; #64; #81; #132; #159; and #176:
Modern governments now consider the asteroid threat seriously and spend vast sums on Spaceguard and Spacewatch projects. Just recently one source reported "Asteroid Bennu is a threat to life on Earth" and another suggested that a large crater discovered under Greenland's ice-cap represents an asteroid impact that produced a "mini ice age" 13,000 years ago. CONCLUSION
In recent centuries the arrival of modern science has allowed hundreds of biblical claims to be scientifically confirmed. Even Sodom and Gomorrah and the fire from "heaven", which skeptics called myths, now look like scientific facts. For 2000 years the Bible has called attention to the threat of global destruction from the sky, but people everywhere didn't believe, remained deluded, and failed to respond appropriately. Bentor, Y.K. 1989 Geological events in the bible, Terra Nova 1: 326-338 Berkowitz, A.E. November 23, 2018 https://www.breakingisraelnews.com/117449/scientists-confirm-sodom-gomorrah/ Bond, A. & Hempsell, M. 2008 A Sumerian Observation of the Köfels' Impact Event, Writers printshop Brophy, J. Biblical cities were destroyed by mid-air asteroid explosion 500 times bigger than Hiroshima 3,700 years ago, archaeologists claim, The Sun 23 November, 2018 https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/7813133/biblical-cities-sodom-gomorrah-destroyed-asteroid-explosion/ Collins, S. A Response to Bryant G. Wood's Critique of Collins' Northern Sodom Theory, Biblical Research Bulletin, 2007, Volume VII, Number 7 Farquhar, P. https://www.businessinsider.com.au/evidence-suggests-enormous-blast-of-heat-wiped-out-sodom-and- gomorrah-2018-11 Frank, H.T. (Editor) 1984 Atlas of the Bible Lands, page B8, Hammond Incorporated Gilat, A. & Vol, A. Sodom and Gomorrah: Fires Created by Ignition of Combustible Gases by Earthquake- Impelled Thermobaric-Hydrothermal Explosions, Journal of Geology & Geophysics, April 28, 2015 Haines, L. Assyrian clay tablet points to 'Sodom and Gomorrah' asteroid, The Register, 31 Mar 2008 https://www.theregister.co.uk/2008/03/31/kofels_asteroid/ Hignett, K. Biblical City Of Sodom Was Blasted To Smithereens By A Massive Asteroid Explosion, Newsweek 11/22/18 https://www.newsweek.com/biblical-city-sodom-was-blasted-smithereens-massive-asteroid-explosion-1227339 Hudson, C.D. (General Editor) 2008 Bible Atlas, Barbour New Scientist, Ice grave of huge meteorite discovered, 24 November, 2018, p. 19 Rational Wiki: Köfels impact event https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Köfels_impact_event Seidel, J. Asteroid Bennu is a threat to life on Earth… https://www.adelaidenow.com.au/news/special-features/in-depth/asteroid -bennu-is-one-of-many-potential-threats-to-life-on-earth-now-nasa-has-a-plan-to-destroy-it/ Spaceguard Centre https://spaceguardcentre.com/an-exploding-meteor-may-have-wiped-out-ancient-dead-sea-communities/ Silvia, P.J. and co-authors, November 2018 https://www.researchgate.net/publication/329755765_The_37kaBP_Middle_Ghor_Event_Catastrophic_ Termination_of_a_Bronze_Age_Civilization Warren, S. 'Temps as hot as the Surface of the Sun': http://www1.cbn.com/cbnnews/cwn/2018/november/did-scientists-find-evidence-of-the-destruction-of-biblical- sodom-exploding-meteor-may-be-to-blame Wood, B.G. Locating Sodom: A Critique of the Northern Proposal, Bible and Spade 23.3, 2007, 78-84 Bab edh-Dhra' excavations and discoveries http://expeditiondeadseaplain.org/?page_id=27Dead Sea Plain.htm Tall El-Hammam Excavation Project https://tallelhammam.com/discoveries https//mysteriousuniverse.org/2018/11/Sodom-and-gomorrah-may-have-been-destroyed-by-a-meteor/ https://www.independent.co.uk/news/sodom-and-gomorrah-destroyed-by-a-comet-say-astronomers-1275763 "Anonymous" relies on scientific discoveries and inductive reasoning,
to prove the Bible, on this website: |