THE
STAR OF BETHLEHEM
Anonymous
(Investigator
164, 2015 September)
Conjunction
Jupiter
and Venus were so close to each other in the northwest night sky on
June 30th that a finger-width of my extended arm covered both.
When
two planets seem to merge as viewed from Earth, it is called a
"conjunction", and the event on the 30th was almost a conjunction.
Venus
and Jupiter are each brighter than Sirius the brightest star and their
close encounter on a clear night is eye-catching.
Star
of Bethlehem
In
previous articles I explained the Star of Bethlehem as a Venus-Jupiter
conjunction.
The
Bible says "the star" not "the planets" went before the "wise men".
This is not an issue since the ancients did not distinguish stars and
planets as we do today. To them planets were "wandering stars" moving
through the background of fixed stars.
A
Venus-Jupiter conjunction occurred on August 12, 3 BC in the eastern
sky, agreeing with the wise men's words that they saw the star "in the
east". Another conjunction occurred ten months later on June 17, 2 BC,
this time in the western sky.
For
this interpretation to succeed the 2 BC conjunction needs to be dated
33 years before Christ's crucifixion since the New Testament shows
Christ died at age 33.
In
his book Eclipse (1999)
astronomer Duncan Steel writes: "Because Passover is at full moon, and
the Crucifixion was on a Friday, only certain dates are feasible, 7
April in 30AD and 3 April in AD33 being the chief candidates…" (p. 21)
Steel opts for AD33. This is 33 years after 2 BC (since there was no
year "0").
The
conjunction hypothesis for the Star of Bethlehem was proposed in 1991
by William Bidelman in the magazine Planetarian,
and by astronomer Fred Schaff in Omni.
In
September 3 BC — a month after the August conjunction — Jupiter came
into conjunction with Regulus the brightest star in the Leo
constellation and symbolic of kingship. Another Jupiter-Regulus
conjunction occurred in May 2 BC a month prior to the Jupiter-Venus
conjunction in June. All these conjunctions and their dates can be
confirmed with computer software.
The
"wise men" were astrologers and would have regarded these conjunctions
as very significant. Perhaps they also knew the Old Testament
prediction about a ruler in Israel who comes out of Bethlehem (Micah 5)
and Daniel's prophecy of an "anointed prince" (9:24-27).
This
still leaves the problem that Herod died in 4 BC and therefore could
not have ordered the murder of infants in Bethlehem in 2 BC. Lately,
however, more researchers have concluded Herod died nearer 1 BC than 4
BC. William Bidelman (1991) argued this, as did Craig Chester (1993)
and Andrew Steinmann (2009).
A guiding star
Details
regarding how the "Star" led the astrologers, and how it stopped above
"the place" where Jesus was, are given in my articles in Investigator 81/18; 88/18; 119/56;
145/32; 149/4; 154/58; 159/21.
In
brief, the astrologers approached Bethlehem from the east after sunset.
The Venus–Jupiter conjunction was in front of them in the western sky
and moved westwards leading them to Bethlehem.
Venus-Jupiter
could appear to stop above a village or even above a specific house if
the astrologers parked their camels on the east side of the village
wall or the east side of the house. The "star" would then seem
stationery for a while above the wall or above the house.
An
experience — 2002
Another
almost-conjunction of Venus and Jupiter prior to the one of June 30th
2015 occurred in May 2002.
During
an evening walk I encountered a woman named Elizabeth who I knew to be
a church member and offered to show her the "Star of Bethlehem".
She
refused to look upwards into the sky and could not be persuaded to do
so.
Many
church-goers seem afraid to check things out. They thereby confirm the
atheists' jibe that "Faith is belief without evidence." Yet the Bible
is crammed with statements that science can confirm or show plausible
including the Star of Bethlehem.
References:
Bidelman,
W.P. The Bimillenary of Christ’s Birth, Planetarian, September 1991, Volume
20 (3)
Chester,
C. The Star of Bethlehem, Imprimis,
December 1993, Volume 22 (12)
Schaff,
F. Omni, Volume 14, No. 1,
October 1991
Steinmann.
A. 2009 Novum Testamentum,
Volume 51, Number 1
http://tifwe.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/The-Star-of-Bethlehem.
pdf
www.al.com/living/index.ssf/2015/06/is_this_what_the_
star_of_bethl.html
www.ips-planetarium.org/?page=a_bidelman1991
www.ingentaconnect.com/content/brill/not/2009/00000051/
000000
01/art00001
www.math.nus.edu.sg/aslaksen/gem-projects/hm/0203-1-18-bethlehem.pdf
www.rt.com/news/270613-jupiter-venus-merge-conjunction/
Scientific
claims of the Bible investigated on this website: